Mozo logo

the mozo blog

Money musings, financial commentary plus the rambling wit and
wisdom of the team from Mozo - Australia's money info zone

0% balance transfers debunked

As winter dies and the stress of losing weight for summer sets in, spare a thought for credit cards that have gorged for months and are entirely unfit for the christmas binge. Now’s the time to think about a balance transfer.

Since you’re a clever sort, you’ll be ogling those super-slim interest rates on Mozo’s credit card comparison page — and hey, who hasn’t snuck a glance at a lusty 0% balance transfer rate? But here’s the rub: that low interest rate could end up costing you money.

“Zounds,” you might reply, and return to your ogling, but bear with us. We’ve been having a bit of a play with our nifty credit card calculator, which spits out the actual cost of a credit card — in place of all this interest rate and balance transfer malarky. The cost is the total you’ll pay in interest and fees to kill off that debt, and as it happens, it’s the best way to judge a credit card.

So let’s peek beneath the balance transfer covers.

  • Citibank’s Clear Card, for example, offers a 0% for 6 months on balance transfers — and a stupendous purchase rate of 11.99% for 12 months. However, if you don’t pay off the transfer within that time, the balance reverts to a corpulent 21.24%.

    For a debt of $3000, with repayments of $200 monthly, you’re looking at a cost of $308 in fees and interest.

  • Suncorp’s Clear Options Standard credit card, by contrast, offers 1.9% for 12 months, and then 17.99% on the outstanding balance transferred. Punch in the same numbers, and the cost of knocking off that same debt is only $135.

    The difference is, well, clear.

  • St George’s Vertigo credit card has a lousier balance transfer offer still, at 2.99% for 6 months. However, after 6 months any unpaid balance doesn’t revert to a sky-high cash rate, but to a quite lovely purchase rate of 12.49%.

    So what does that all mean? The same debt, with the same repayments, will cost $252 to pay off with St George.

And if, ahem, your repayments drop to only $100 each month, while that debt blows out to $5000, here’s the cost of each balance transfer in fees and interest:

Citibank Clear Card: $4639

SunCorp Clear Options Standard: $2304

St George Vertigo: $1974

The conclusion? Pay of that balance ASAP! But if that isn’t feasible, don’t just grab the best headline rate: it could be twice as expensive.

Savings left for a rainy day

After much debate and conjecture, the Federal government finally issued what has been widely labeled as a cautious and narrow response relative to the broad and expansive scope of the Henry Review of the taxation system. Indeed, only a smattering of the 138 recommendations outlined in the review have been taken on board for this round of reform. Left off the list were the anticipated new tax concessions on savings. Attention instead turned squarely towards superannuation with Australia’s aging population looming as a big issue.

While a lot of the focus will be on the exclusions, there were some significant steps made towards reform yesterday, the three cornerstones being:
* A 40% tax on mining industry profits, labeled as a resource rent tax on their “super profits” and netting the government $12 billion in forecast revenue between 2012-13.
* Increasing the superannuation guarantee from 9% to 12% by 2020 with the government to contribute $500 for people earning up to $37000.
* A cut in the company tax rate from 30% to 28% by 2015. Small businesses will get the cut by 2013 as well as receiving a range of other new benefits.

The changes announced yesterday have been earmarked as the first step in a wave of changes in enacting revolutionary tax reform. The government has explicitly stated that there will be more announcements in the future on savings incentives, as one of central issues to be addressed in the government’s second term agenda. This still leaves both financial institutions and consumers in the lurch for the foreseeable future however. Many hoped that by increasing bank-held deposits, the saving concessions would help reduce funding costs by alleviating the need to rely so heavily on foreign debt, thereby reducing the need for banks to enact mortgage rate rises above that of the Reserve Bank.

So all up it’s much the same for most of the players in the banking sector, at least for now anyway. All eyes now turn to Martin Place tomorrow, as we see what effect these changes (or lack thereof), will have on the Reserve Bank’s monthly cash rate announcement. Mozo’s rate chasers will be out in force, so be sure to check our Reserve Bank interest rates page from 2:30pm tomorrow to get all the latest news and rate changes as they happen.

Banking comparisons made easy at mozo.com.au

Saving to be made less taxing

The words ‘tax’ and ‘exciting’ make strange bedfellows at the best of times, but it really can be described as a potentially exciting time for Australians on the tax front. Consumers look set for a double boost this Sunday, when the Federal Government finally releases its findings and decisions derived from the ‘Henry review’ of the tax system. Chaired by the head of the Federal Treasury, Ken Henry, the review has been labeled as a “root-and-branch” review of Australia’s tax system, and by all reports consumers could see gains with regards to both their savings and their mortgages as a result of some of the potentially adopted findings. Dr Henry handed over the report to Treasurer Wayne Swan in December 2009 and since then, Treasury officials have been working on the government’s response to the review.

In terms of Australia’s banking climate, the review looks set to cause a possibly portentous shake-up of the savings account market. Australia is one of the few countries in the developed world to currently tax bank savings at the full rate, a tag which by all reports will be shed soon, with the government preparing to offer significant tax breaks on savings. Whilst the extent of these breaks are as yet unknown, they are unlikely to match the UK model of which where individuals can deposit close to $17,000 (£10,200) tax-free. Dr. Henry is a known admirer of the UK system, yet many in the media are purporting rumours that something similar to the concessions currently in place for superannuation accounts will be announced instead. However, considering the range of options available in terms of size, scope and delivery, there’s no way to be sure till we hear what Wayne Swan has to say himself.

The tax break would also be a huge boost for Australia’s banks as it could generate billions in additional deposits, potentially lowering their funding costs through reducing the reliance on overseas finance. As a result of this, consumers could potentially receive a boost with regards to home loans payments. The banks have been very quick to use high funding costs to justify mortgage rate rises above that of the Reserve Bank‘s cash rate increases. With funding cost pressures alleviated to a significant degree, the government may well turn around and use this savings deposit boost as political leverage aimed at forcing banks to keep mortgage rates down and in turn, voters happy.

Either way, as far as the banking industry is concerned, consumers look to finally be on the receiving end of some good news. Mozo’s Rate Chasers will have a full wrap-up of all the implications for both deposit and lending accounts here on Monday, so be sure to check back to see what all the new changes mean for you.

Compare savings accounts at mozo.com.au

Cracking the da Stevens Code

RBA Governor Glenn Stevens has released the text of another speech, this time to business leaders in Toowoomba. And so it’s time for analysts, pundits, commentators and generally interested persons to pick over his themes, his words and the general vibe of the thing, to try and second-guess what the Reserve Bank of Australia will do to interest rates next month.

As always, there’s something for everyone. References to good economic news and references to risks and uncertainties. If you want to predict that rates will go up in May, you can quote him on the speed of the rate cuts in 2008/9 and suggest that he’s paving the way for faster rather than slower increases. If you want to predict that the RBA will pause in May and leave rates steady, you can quote him on the need to leave flexibility in how we respond to the way the recovery unfolds. And there’s plenty each way in his analysis of the global economic recovery.

But look closer. We’ve found an ingenious code hidden in the speeches of the RBA Governor. And an astonishing truth… unveiled at last!

He tells us that, when responding to the GFC, the RBA cut rates by 375 basis points over 5 months. And that so far, they’ve responded to the recovery by increasing them by 125 basis points over 7 months, “…which is still only about a third the pace of the earlier declines.” Now 375 over 5 equals 75, but notice that 125 over 7 is well short of a third of this – it is not even a quarter! Rather than a numerical error, this is actually a clue. To get to exactly one-third, you need 200 over 8… and a 75 basis point increase in May would do exactly that! Unbelievable!

A 75 basis point increase next month is a shocking conclusion, well outside what most observers predict, but one clearly supported by the clever trail of clues he has left. But, rest assured that this would be the final increase: his speech contains 3133 words, and 3+1+3+3 = 10, and 1+0=1, ie he’s telling us that there is just one last rate rise.

Silly? Yes, but it is no less scientific than some other predictions people make from picking apart his speeches for clues. The RBA has told us clearly that there is likely to be a little bit more to go, but that the timing is up in the air. That’s all the clues they are going to give us. Maybe May, maybe June, maybe both, maybe neither.

So instead of predicting what the RBA might do, here at Mozo we’ll keep our eyes on what financial providers do in response. Every month, Mozo’s Rate Chasers update Reserve Bank interest rates with information about home loan rate rises as it comes in. And of course, you can find everything you need in our extensive database of rates, fees and features, for home loans, credit cards, savings accounts, term deposits, personal loans and bank accounts.

mozo.com.au. we chase. you save.

Are new charges really in Westpac’s interest?

Headlines were made yesterday when Westpac announced it will charge interest on interest charges and fees on all its credit card accounts, starting in June. While media commentators and consumer groups savaged the bank, and the Treasurer labelled it a “serial offender”, the new charges are more or less standard practice — at least among the big banks. So why all the fuss?

On the one hand, as Westpac itself points out, the changes will have a “tiny effect on balances”, apparently 67 cents a month for those affected. Moreover, Westpac is simply coming into line with the other Big 4s – so why single it out for being a late adopter of minimal charges?

The problem is that, at the end of the day, it is another tricksy initiative: fiddling with the fine print to raise revenue without altering the headline rate. And if the net result is in fact tiny, is it really worth the media storm that’s now engulfed the bank?

You have to think Westpac’s PR department has either had a really big St Patrick’s Day or been taken hostage by the bean counters. Consumer sentiment towards Australia’s largest home loan lender is at an all-time low, following its 45 basis point rate rise in December and the subsequent smoothie-fueled furore. Gail Kelly’s leaked comments about rising funding costs – and possible interest rate hikes of a further 30 to 40 basis points – have hardly helped. And profits are already up a third on the previous year, while Westpac was awarded the double-edged title of “World’s most profitable bank” by the famed Boston Consulting Group.

Justifying new charges in a general banking climate of fee cuts is a difficult proposition. At the same time, slamming a bank for catching up to its peers on a minor new charge is more media stunt than serious consumer advocacy.

Stay tuned for our wrap up of sneaky credit card fees — who’s leading the charge, and who simply has bad PR.

Compare credit cards at mozo.com.au

Made in the US

As GFC mud was slung in the States, Congress ducked for cover behind its credit card reforms — which were passed in May last year and have just come into effect. Whether similar changes should be expected in Australia remains uncertain, and will be some time off if they do eventuate. As far as the US reforms go, there’s both good and bad news for consumers.

On the upside, random interest rate changes have been abolished, as the centrepiece of the reform. How and when banks can raise interest rates is now tightly regulated, and they must give at least 45 days’ notice before increasing their interest rates. Furthermore, a review of penalty rates and fees is scheduled for later this year.

The major lenders have responded, however, by hiking up fees, and inventing new ones. So your balance transfer with JPMorgan Chase will now attract a 5% fee. Let’s hope that one doesn’t emigrate down under.

And credit card rewards have also been hit with various creative penalties, such as no points accrued on purchases if the customer is late with a payment (courtesy of American Express co-branded cards).

One of the big wins (for consumers) is restrictions on credit limits, and more stringent credit cards application processes, with lenders tightening up access to credit. Which may seem rough to those struggling to find a provider, but will hopefully lead to fewer borrowing more than they can afford.

Australia is usually a couple of years behind American credit card trends (for example, the 0% balance transfer), so it’ll be interesting to see which, if any, changes trickle through to the domestic market.

compare credit cards at mozo.com.au

Home loan rates up by more than RBA, as predicted

I warned you.  Westpac were off the mark early on Tuesday morning with an aggressive term deposit rate, and I blogged that it would put pressure on home loan rates to increase beyond the RBA.  Bingo!  Westpac was first out with that announcement as well, so clearly they’d planned the whole thing: put out the term deposit good news first to take the sting off the home loan bad news.

St George are matching the Westpac term deposit offer, so no prizes for guessing what their home loan rates will do.

Now watch the other sheep follow the leader.

Compare home loans at mozo.com.au

Compare term deposits at mozo.com.au

One Flew Over The Cash Rate

By Andrew Burger 30 November 2009 9:50amHome loans, Interest rates

Yet another RBA announcement looms. Apparently someone (God, Galileo or the Greenwich Mean Time Monster) has organised calendar dates in an effort to inflict as much pain on borrowers as possible – seriously, how can there be so many Tuesdays in every month?

In light of this startling revelation, we thought it would be a good chance to gauge the thoughts of the mortgage community who are, unfortunately enough, staring down the barrel of 18 months of gradual pain.

To make this amazingly easy for us, The Daily Telegraph have put together a short survey around Tuesday’s meeting, which can be completed at this very clickable green link. For those of you in the community who think the Reserve Board is out of touch, or would like to pen an imaginary message to RBA overlord Glenn Stevens, then you will find this a convenient, interwebs based soap box.

So despite the cash rate reaching 50 year lows, and staying that way almost long enough for even the most indecisive property owner to fix a pretty special rate, the Monetary powers that be are again falling back on their old tools. Now it appears people must brace themselves for a good, healthy dose of monthly electroshock therapy. Let’s just hope it ends better than it did for Jack Nicholson.

Need help with the pain? Compare Home Loans with Mozo to find a better a deal.

Size Matters

Yes, you heard me. Unfortunately for all you people out there with big huge ones, the truth is finally out. The smaller they are, the better. Mortgages that is; and there are no pills or herbs that can help you. On the upside, you can still benefit from a competitive interest rate and a well-structured repayment plan.

So how do you make your enlarged debt shrink sooner? First of all, jump into a cold shower, refresh yourself, and then log on to a comparison site like this one and do the research. There’s almost always a better interest rate to be found and it’s probably not going to be with one of the major banks.

Secondly, once you’ve found your desired financial partner, you’ll have the option of making weekly, fortnightly or monthly payments. Now here comes the maths…

Let’s take a mortgage of $300,000 to be paid off over 25 years at an interest rate of 6.00%. We can break it down into three repayment methods: monthly, fortnightly and weekly. (Those with high debt and low attention spans can skip straight to the results.)

Monthly:

Total Interest: $279,871.26
Payment: $1,932.90
Time (months): 300

There are fewer actual payments to be made, so the bank has to ask for higher repayments to cover the cost of the loan over the 25-year period.

Fortnightly:

Total Interest: $279,535.51
Payment: $891.59
Time (fortnights): 650

Now we’re looking slightly better on the interest payments front; however, those extra payments you’re making haven’t had much effect, because the bank averages your payments out over the 25-year period. You’re paying slightly less every fortnight but it’s made up by the fact that there are more actual repayment dates.

Weekly:

Total Interest: $279,391.57
Payment: $445.69
Frequency (fortnights): 1300

OK then, basically you’ll only save a total of $479.69 in interest payments over the life of your 25-year loan by choosing the weekly option. Big deal.

So here’s the secret: pay your mortgage using a bi-weekly method. The bank’s fortnightly method is still 26 payments a year like the bi-weekly, but it’s at a reduced rate so they keep you as a customer for the full 25 years. What you SHOULD be paying every fortnight is simply half of the monthly payment (otherwise known as bi-weekly), which in this case is $1932.90 divided by 2, or $966.45.

At $74.86 more than the fortnightly payment, the bi-weekly makes a big difference:

Bi-Weekly

Total Interest: $228,991.19
Payment: $966.45
Frequency (bi-weekly): 650

In effect, using the bi-weekly method, you’re making one extra repayment a year and you save $50,880.07 in interest payments over the life of the loan.

For all of you who’ve made it to the end of the article, you’ll shave 5 years off the life of your loan, bringing it to 20 years! Not a bad result for 2 minutes of reading.

Compare home loans with mozo.com.au

UBank refusing to back down in Savings Account War

UBank’s USaver, already quite the consumer champion, raised its rate by 0.35% today (effective next Tuesday), lifting it once again head and shoulders above the competition. Having sat out the last Reserve Bank rate rise, eyes were firmly aimed at the NAB-backed upstart to see whether it had perhaps conceded in its revolutionary push towards top spot in the savings account market. Alas for ING Direct and co., UBank had no such ideas, and have once again set themselves at the head of the pack.

Also of great news to existing account holders, was UBank’s rate assurance last night, declaring that until the end of the year at least, that USaver interest rate will not fall below that of their chief rivals (including introductory promotional rates), directly labelling accounts by ANZ, BankWest, Westpac, ING Direct and Commonwealth Bank as their chief competition (though surprisingly no Raboplus…).

So the time’s never been better to snap up a USaver account, once again a good 0.2% or more above its rivals. Get in quick while the rate assurances are hot I say!

Want to make up your own mind? Compare Savings Accounts on Mozo.com.au